🧭️ Navigating the WR Craze
In today's Fantasy Life newsletter, the team previews the Carolina Panthers' 2023 outlook, a WR-heavy Fantasy Football draft strategy and more.
Adapt or die trying, fantasy drafters…
In today’s Fantasy Life Newsletter:
- A strategy to help lean into WR-heavy drafts.
- What Now? Find out how you really feel.
- Quad SZN returns. A BIG sighting.
- Panthers Preview: In or out on Miles Sanders?
- It's 6/7. Take it away, Dwain McFarland…
Fantasy drafters are flocking to the high-flying superstars of the gridiron in the early rounds. Get it? Flocking and high-flying? Yeah, we are talking about the guys that do their damage primarily via the air — the WRs!
Last season we saw some of the craziest WR ADPs ever, and the price tags have increased. According to Underdog, the top 50 WRs are going 3.9 spots higher on average.
Due to this trend, we have insane RB value falling down the board, which might lead us to zig while others zag and snap up multiple RBs early.
While that sounds great on the surface (and I am a proponent of trying it at times), the challenge with going all-in on RBs early is drafters aren’t relenting at WR after the first four rounds.
Historically, you might have made up for a weak start at WR in the early-middle rounds. Unfortunately, on Underdog, the WR avalanche can be too deep to dig our way out for two reasons:
By the time we start taking WRs, the QUALITY is lower than in recent years.
It is difficult to draft the QUANTITY of solid options needed to give us a chance to hit on enough WRs.
Unlike RB, volume isn’t king in WR land.
Talent is king, and if a WR can’t earn targets, getting on the field doesn’t matter. The supply of high-quality target-earning humans is much lower than the demand, and the market has figured this out.
Q: So, how do we combat the WR craze?
A: Embrace it.
That’s right, our best chance of survival might be embracing the avalanche. However, we must have a plan for the RB position to pull that off. Luckily, we have some unique opportunities at RB — especially if we pick from an early or middle position on Underdog.
🗻 The M&M RB Strategy
Two RBs in high-quality offenses are going in Rounds 5 and 7. Both have RB1 upside but are shrouded by uncertainty, leading to lower ADPs.
🗻 Joe Mixon (56 ADP)
He could still face suspension, but the Bengals haven’t added any significant competition. Cincinnati’s lack of offseason movement doesn’t mean Mixon is in the clear, but it doesn’t hurt. Mixon has deteriorated as a rusher over the past few seasons but was highly active in the passing game last year on a top-five offense.
He has averaged 15.2, 16.8 and 15.0 points over the last three years in half-PPR formats. That is RB1-worthy.
🗻 Alexander Mattison (77 ADP)
Mattison signed a new contract this offseason with the Vikings, and there are rumors that Dalvin Cook could be a cap casualty.
A trade would free up $11 million, and a release would save the team $9 million. The team tried to move him during the NFL Draft but couldn’t get anything finalized. Recently, the Vikings’ social media featured Mattison on their banner, not Cook.
In games without Cook, Mattison has finished as the RB47, RB4, RB7, RB6, RB8 and RB13. Forecasting similar finishes on a larger sample doesn’t always work, but at a minimum, Mattison has RB1 upside.
While it is risky, it is worth building at least a few lineups around Mixon & Mattison because we can offset the WR avalanche AND access upside at RB.
Each of these builds leaves multiple outs for QB stacks later and has some natural Week 17 correlation already established.
This strategy isn’t for the faint of heart because we embrace unknowns. However, the payoff is potentially huge (which is what we care about in top-heavy contests).
The key is drafting with the expectation that Mixon and Mattison WILL provide you with RB1-worthy performances. So, from Round 9 on, draft as if you took them much earlier!
Head over to Underdog and use the Code LIFE to receive a 100% first deposit match on up to $100! Good luck!
Welcome, degenerates. We don’t unplug just because the NFL does. You’re reading this newsletter because you’re here for the long haul. “What now, Cooter?” Each week I’ll break down ways to survive the off-season.
🔎 Survival Tip #12: Find Out How You Really Feel
We’ve all heard of the Coin Flip strategy, right? You flip a coin on a tough decision to let heads or tails decide, but the outcome is only a suggestion. You don’t have to follow suit.
In fact, research has shown that by using a coin flip as an aid, it can result in individuals experiencing “stronger feeling[s] of suddenly knowing what they want.” So as any true scientist would, I put this theory to the ultimate fantasy football test.
That’s right, I joined a 4-team, best ball league with three of my buddies with a bottle of tequila on the line.
The prize made it meaningful.
The small league size made it novel enough to be unpredictable. And like I always tell my husband, best ball leagues don’t count. They don’t add to the overall number of leagues you’re in because they don’t require any in-season management.
So, it’s fine. Seriously, it’s not a big deal, babe!
All jokes aside, this draft was exactly what I needed to find out how I really feel about certain draft strategies and players.
Late QB? Zero RB? My guys?
This was my metaphorical coin flip. And yes, I experienced stronger feelings of suddenly knowing what I want. Science!
Here are three things that I learned about myself. Will these be meaningful for you? I don’t know, flip your own metaphorical coin.
I need to leave with one of: Patrick Mahomes, Jalen Hurts, Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, or Lamar Jackson. Can I wait on QB and be fine? Sure. But will I be happy? NO.
If I don’t get Bijan Robinson, Rhamondre Stevenson, or Tony Pollard, I’m about to have a bad time.
I still can’t stop drafting DeVonta Smith.
I may be a Saints fan, but I sure don’t draft like one. Sorry, Michael Thomas. You can’t hurt me anymore.
*Disclaimer, I still cannot draft on Underdog in Louisiana. Please call my local representatives for me. Thanks.
The best part about this 4-team draft is that my team is STACKED. I mean, so are the other teams, but mine is, too.
wOw MuSt Be A FoUr TeAm LeAgUe https://t.co/sQDHxLtrPt
And now, I have clarity for my big-league drafts. The haze has been lifted, and I know what I need to do. Now it’s your turn. Find a way to shake things up. Flip the coin. Find out how you really feel.
🤣 You can’t bet on games. But sometimes you have to gamble…
📂 His rushing profile looks fantastic. But there ARE questions.
🏈 Can this QB regain his old form? His best practice since arriving.
⚖️ This former NFL player is down 100+ pounds. How did he do it?
🍴 A three-way TE rotation? The 2022 draft pick is HUNGRY.
🎬 Beastmode hitting the box office? That is a wild premise.
🦵️ Quadzilla returns. Let’s be honest, he could also be Glutezilla…
🏋️♂️ Will the vet WR be ready for camp? He says he will be back to form.
👨👩👦 Dynasty is special. You are building a family.
Fantasy Life senior analyst Ian Hartitz is breaking down all 32 NFL teams over the next two months. Let’s take a look at the Panthers, who revamped their entire offense, starting with the No. 1 overall pick in the NFL Draft…
😎 RBs
Miles Sanders (Ian’s RB22)
Chuba Hubbard (RB57)
Raheem Blackshear (RB105)
The former Eagles RB has averaged five yards per carry for his career while demonstrating true flashes of big-play ability. In fact, Sanders posted a 15% 10-plus yard attempt rate in 2021 and followed that up with 13% in 2022, which ranked ninth-best among RBs.
And yet, it’s hard to not look at that high-end efficiency with just a bit of skepticism. Dual-threat QB Jalen Hurts regularly helped open up wider rushing lanes thanks to his read option threat, and it certainly didn’t hurt that Sanders was running behind PFF’s top-ranked offensive line last season.
PFF Elusive Rating, which measures the success and impact of a runner with the ball independently of the blocking, does a good job of illustrating Sanders’ game. He’s more than capable of getting what’s blocked and can get from zero to 60 in a hurry, but there isn’t much consistent wiggle or high-end ability to pick up yards after contact here. Here are Sanders's elusive ratings:
2022: 55.1 (No. 22 among 42 qualifying RBs)
2021: 51.9 (No. 24)
2020: 59.9 (No. 16)
2019: 47.9 (No. 31)
Style points don’t equate to extra fantasy points, so Sanders is free to pick up yards and TDs in whatever manner he sees fit. Still, a quick highlight recap of last season shows all sorts of examples of the 26-year-old back mightily benefiting from one gaping hole after another.
Perhaps the Panthers’ reigning 21st-ranked offensive line in PFF run blocking grade can take their game to another level in 2023, but they largely declined to add any sort of real reinforcements to the group either through the draft or free agency.
Good fantasy RBs are more prevalent in bad real-life offenses than any position other than QB, so Sanders doesn’t need to be overly efficient with his opportunities to be productive in fantasy as long as he gets the heavy majority of touches in this backfield.
Of course, projecting whether or not Sanders will get a true three-down role depends on which offseason quote you want to use.
Back in February, Panthers RBs coach Duce Staley said that he believes in using three RBs and noted that playing at the RB position is like being “in a car wreck". Then in April, Sanders said that reuniting with Staley was the main reason he signed with the Panthers and that “they know I’m a three-down back".
Sanders did indeed see a far bigger pass-down role when Staley was the Eagles' RBs coach in 2019 and 2020 (115 targets) compared to 2021 and 2022 (60), although that could also be more of a result of playing alongside a dual-threat QB. It’s also fair to wonder if Sanders regressed as a pass-catcher since then, as he joined Derrick Henry as the two worst-rated backs in PFF receiving grade last year.
Ultimately, my bigger concern is the reality that Sanders never averaged even 14 carries per game in the 2019 and 2020 seasons under Staley. Those offenses made sure to also keep guys like Jordan Howard and Boston Scott heavily involved, so Hubbard and Blackshear could still eat into Sanders's rushing workload in 2023, even if they're not big names.
The Panthers obviously paid Sanders plenty of money for a reason, but the history of RBs changing teams in free agency has been rather brutal in recent years.
Sanders’s path to success will necessitate seizing a three-down role or at least something close to it. While that's possible, his floor could be low as an early-down grinder for what sure looks like one of the NFL’s bottom-10 offenses.
I’m out on Sanders at his current RB17 ADP, as guys like Cam Akers (RB24), Rachaad White (RB25), and James Conner (RB27) offer similar hopes for three-down roles in bad offenses and are going multiple rounds later over at Underdog Fantasy. There are also plenty of upside WR3 options available in this ADP range, so don’t go out of your way to land anyone on this likely-to-be sad Panthers offense.
How About The Revamped WR Room?
Bruce Arians only has 1 championship with Tom Brady, yet I have 2 with Brady from last year alone (superflex). You tell me who's the more impressive football coach